Site Search

Quotation Favorite Quotes

"Books are the most mannerly of companions, accessible at all times, in all moods, frankly declaring the author's mind, without offense."


— Amos Bronson Alcott

Reader's Link

 Reader's Link


Ever worked a weird low-level job?

Nickel and Dimed, on (not) getting by in America.

Title: Nickel and Dimed, on (not) getting by in America.
By: Barbara Ehrenreich

Haven't we all worked at some kind of wretched job at some point in our lives? And thought to ourselves "I am so over-educated for this!" In this book, Ms. Ehrenreich conducts an experiment, using herself for the test subject: find work in meaningless jobs and write about the experience of being subservient to rules of management. Can she survive on a low minimum wage, plus find a place to live, plus enough to eat, plus clothes to wear? You are going to laugh out loud at how Ms. Ehrenreich joins a maid service, and has to strap a vacuum to her back while going through hallways, dusting wainscoting and wiping down counter tops with the same dirty cloth! I cried laughing when I read how she had to sort clothes at a famous department store on hangers and re-display the inventory in just the right spot, then see how the next day that display is in another area! She kind-of makes friends, or comrades, and their working class stories are real. The writer returns to her motel room at night to write about the indignity of the lower working class with deep insight. Perfectly appropriate right here, right now. Also available as an audio book.

View similarly tagged posts: non-fiction, history, biography

Posted by pollockl on Oct. 4, 2009 at 1:24 p.m.
4 Comments

Comments

October 15, 2009 at 10:51 a.m.:

This review strikes me as pretty condescending. Most people who work low-level jobs aren't slumming it; they have no choice. Ehrenreich's book is excellent but these comments make it sound frivolous and uncaring, which could not be further from the truth.

November 3, 2010 at 10:35 a.m.:

I agree with you that whoever wrote the review used the wrong language. Calling low paying jobs "meaningless" is condescending. Not everyone is able to negotiate peace treaties, write great novels, discover life saving medical procedures, etc. I don't remember laughing while reading this book. I remember being sad that so many who work so hard for so little are treated so badly. It's a great book and I wish more Republicans would read it.

January 28, 2011 at 1:30 p.m.:

I agree--the review by "pollockl" is not only condenscending, it misses the point. The author was asking a big political question: can the working class really survive in America today? The author did the old-school type of investigative journalism, taking a series of jobs and trying to see if she could actually pay the rent and survive. It was a struggle and some of the tasks at work were unnecessarily demeaning. This is an excellent book with much more depth than what the original review suggests.

June 21, 2011 at 1:14 p.m.:

I've yet to read this book for myself, which I will do here shortly, but I've encountered it in lecture and I am appalled by the review presented here. Clearly the reader has missed the objective of Ehrenreich's work, which strives to show the dignity of low wage workers in an unfair system.

I motion the library staff promote the book but remove pollockl's synopsis

Post a Comment

Book Discussion KitsCheck Out Our Book Discussion Kits!

To help your book discussion group, we've gathered a collection of popular paperback titles and sorted them into kits which can be sent to you upon request.

Upcoming Book EventsUpcoming Book Events...

There are no book events scheduled for the next 4 days.... See the Online Calendar for a full list of library events.